Lighting Round, 10th Edition (4min32sec)
(Link to video)
Sometimes a clip party participant will pull a DVD out of their collection, ready to extract a clip they know will be terrific. An ESTABLISHED CLASSIC from cinematic history.
Until they watch it, and realize it will never work as a three-minute clip.
Case in point: the crop duster attack from Alfred Hitchcock’s North by Northwest.
For one thing, the sequence is too long, if you include Cary Grant getting off the bus, waiting, wondering whether the person across the road is the person he is supposed to meet, waiting, hearing and seeing the plane in the distance, waiting, and the realizing THIS FUCKING PLANE IS HEADING STRAIGHT AT ME.
In truth, you need much more than even that, because for the scene to really work you need to know why this well-dressed urbanite is on this lonely rural road to begin with. I.e. to say, THE STAKES. Otherwise it’s just shots of a guy running from a plane intercut with shots of the same guy falling down in a rear-screen projection room back in Hollywood.
The sequence works because it is an ambush of both Roger Thornhill (Grant) and the audience’s expectations. Divorced from its setup, the scene just falls flat.
An experienced clip party goer (in this case, my brother) will admit defeat at this point, and select 20 seconds of this iconic scene to submit instead for the Lightning Round, along with a choice moment from Tommy Boy.